This investigation analyses feedback from nearly 100 people who had used or tried to access community mental health services provided by Birmingham and Solihull Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust (BSMHFT) in South and East Birmingham.

05/02/2024
By Healthwatch Birmingham
Investigations 2024

The study identified issues around:

  • Quality of service: 49% rated NHS community mental health services as poor or very poor.
  • Waiting times: 22% waited 3-6 months for a first appointment following referral.
  • Over-reliance on prescription medication: 57% received prescription medication compared to only 19% that received talking therapy.
  • Consistency of care: 46% could not contact the service to get the help they needed.
  • Care planning and review: 59% did not have a care plan.

While just over half the people who shared their experiences said they were treated with kindness, dignity and respect by community mental health services, they also told us about the improvements they would like to the care they received. These include:

  • Improve access to appointments and reduce waiting times for treatment.
  • Offer people reviews after treatment and re-refer people if more support is needed.
  • Ensure that care and support is personalised following a discussion with people about their needs.
  • Produce and follow good care plans.
  • Offer more than just medication.

In response, BSMHFT has provided Healthwatch Birmingham with an action plan outlining how the Trust intends to tackle the issues identified in the report, such as:

  • Collaborative, needs led, care planning to ensuring that all discussion will be done jointly with service users and will address their needs.
  • Meet and Greet staff to support service users when they attend community hubs for their appointments.
  • Clear guidance for managing appointment cancellations, so individuals are contacted to be told why their appointment has been cancelled and when their rescheduled appointment will occur.

In six months’ time, Healthwatch Birmingham will publish an impact report detailing the progress made in delivering the improvements BSMHFT has committed to making, to ensure that people with mental health issues in Birmingham can get the essential care they need.


Experiences of NHS Community mental health services in South and East Birmingham Download File (pdf 1.60 MB)

It can take a lot of courage for people to seek help with mental health issues, and they need confidence that they will get the prompt and sensitive support they need. Unfortunately, our report shows that is too rarely the case in Birmingham. Healthwatch Birmingham welcomes BSMHFT’s stated intentions to make changes to improve the experience of service-users and address the staff shortages at the root of many of the problems, but we need to see the results in practice. Early and people-centred intervention to support those who seek help is vital. Without it, the consequences can be serious and sometimes even tragic. – Richard Burden, Chair, Healthwatch Birmingham

Related Reports

Impact report: Better mental health support for children and young people in Birmingham

Following engagement with service users, their families/carers and Healthwatch Birmingham, Forward Thinking Birmingham (FTB) has made a number of important changes to mental health support for children and young people in Birmingham

Impact Reports 2022
Read More

Is every person in Birmingham who is diagnosed with a serious mental illness provided with a care plan?

Is every person in Birmingham who is diagnosed with a serious mental illness provided with a care plan? was written following a review of local findings about the provision of care plans for mental health patients. Overall the majority of people that needed a mental health care plan had one (80%). Nevertheless there were a significant number without a plan (20%).

Investigations 2016
Read More

Improving mental health services for Birmingham service users

‘Improving mental health services for Birmingham service users’ details changes made by Birmingham and Solihull Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust (BSMHFT)  to its community mental health services (CMHTs), after patients shared their issues with medicine management, access to care and appointments, respect and communication.

Impact Reports 2019
Read More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *